Most people are hesitant to start a newsletter because they seem harder than they are. They sit down to write and immediately start thinking of subject lines, graphics, links, call to actions, formatting, what to talk about, what to sell, and then wonder if anyone would even care. Suddenly what was supposed to be a simple email turns into a two hour wrestling match without a blinking cursor.

A good newsletter doesn’t need twelve sections or some revolutionary idea that nobody has ever heard. It just needs a simple structure that helps you turn what you already know into something people can use. That’s where the story, lesson, action formula comes in.

Tell me something. Teach me something. Give me something to do. Nail those three pieces, and you’ve got a newsletter format you can come back to week after week without reinventing the wheel.

Start with the story. And before you say, “I’m not a storyteller,” I’m not talking about writing the next great American novel. A story can be something a customer said yesterday, a mistake you’ve made, a question from a prospect, a conversation with an employee, or something that happened in your business that made you stop and think. The point isn’t to entertain for the sake of entertaining. The story is there to pull the reader into the idea and give the lesson a place to land.

Next comes the lesson. Ask yourself a simple question: What does the story teach? Maybe it’s that customers remember how you make them feel. Maybe it’s that speed matters more than perfection. Maybe it’s that your best marketing ideas are hiding inside the questions that customers ask you. This is where you take the story and turn it into something useful. Don’t try to teach seven things at a time. Pick one clear takeaway and make it easy for the reader to understand.

Then finish with the action. This is the part a lot of newsletters skip. They want to give the readers something interesting to think about, but they never tell them what to actually do with it. Give them one simple next step they can take right away, whether thats calling three past customers, reviewing the last five questions a prospect asked, or rewriting a headline on their website. The goal is for the reader to finish the email thinking, I can actually do that.

That’s the whole formula: Story → Lesson → Action. The stories will change. The lessons will change. The actions will change. But the structure stays the same, which makes your newsletter easier to write and easier for your audience to read week after week.

Here’s where AI becomes ridiculously useful. Most people don’t struggle with newsletters because they have nothing to say. Their best ideas are just scattered across customer conversations, sales calls, notes, questions, and everyday business experiences. AI can help take that raw material and shape it into a clean Story → Lesson → Action newsletter without you staring at a blank screen.

The key is to give AI the ingredients instead of just saying, “Write me a newsletter.” Tell it what happened, what stood out, what the lesson is, and what you want the reader to do next. Think of AI as your editor and organizer, not your replacement. You bring the experience and personality. AI helps package it faster.

Copy + Paste Prompt

1️⃣Podcast: The Marketing Millennials
A solid resource for practical marketing ideas, content strategy, and real-world examples you can borrow from when building your own newsletter. It’s especially useful for seeing how one strong idea can be turned into a compelling story and takeaway.

2️⃣Article: How to Write a Good Sentence — a Damn Good One
This Copyblogger article is a useful reminder that great newsletters don’t need to sound complicated. They need clear, engaging sentences that keep people moving from one thought to the next — exactly what you want when using the Story → Lesson → Action formula.

3️⃣Book: Everybody Writes by Ann Handley
One of the best books for anyone who says, “I’m not really a writer.” Ann Handley breaks business writing down into practical ways to communicate more clearly, tell better stories, and create content people actually want to read.

Done-For-You: Want me to run this play for you? My Buzz Packages are designed for business owners who want expert results without the guesswork. We handle the strategy, the content, and the execution. The Promotion Sprint .

Done-With-You: Need a custom playbook for your specific situation? Book a 1-on-1 Strategy Call with me. We’ll spend an hour building a roadmap tailored to your exact goals. .

Do-It-Yourself: Want the tools to run these plays yourself? The Outlaw AI Toolkit gives you 9 expert-trained AI assistants to handle your marketing in minutes a day.